Core Plot Summary
The story unfolds entirely in a sweltering jury room, where 12 men are tasked with deciding the fate of a young working-class defendant accused of murdering his father. Initially, 11 jurors vote guilty, convinced by circumstantial evidence and personal biases. Only Juror 8 holds out, arguing that the case deserves careful reexamination. Over the course of deliberations, he challenges each piece of evidence, sowing doubt in his peers one by one. By the end, the jury unanimously votes not guilty, having set aside prejudice to uphold the principle of reasonable doubt.