Core Narrative Summary
The story centers on a British naval ship that mutinies during a long, brutal voyage in the 1800s. After the crew splits into two groups—one remaining on the damaged ship, the other fleeing on a small lifeboat—both face extreme hunger, exposure, and moral collapse. When survivors from both sides return to Britain years later, a high-stakes trial unfolds to determine who is guilty of mutiny and murder. Grann weaves together historical records, survivor testimonies, and modern research to unpack the conflicting truths of the event.