Keyword Guide · book-summary

We Were Liars: Summary, Themes, and Analysis

E. Lockhart’s We Were Liars is a suspenseful young adult novel that explores the dark secrets of the wealthy Sinclair family. Through the perspective of Cadence Sinclair, readers navigate a maze of memory, privilege, and tragedy on a private island.

Get Readi.AI (iOS) Open App Redirect

we were liars summary study illustration

The Setting: Beechwood Island

The story takes place on Beechwood, a private island owned by the wealthy Sinclair patriarch, Harris Sinclair. Every summer, the family gathers here to maintain their image of perfection. The 'Liars'—Cadence, her cousins Johnny and Mirren, and their friend Gat—form a tight-knit group that struggles with the heavy expectations and internal rivalries of the Sinclair estate. The island serves as both a sanctuary and a prison, highlighting the divide between the family's public facade and their private dysfunction.

The Mystery of Summer Fifteen

During Summer Fifteen, a mysterious accident leaves Cadence with severe head trauma and debilitating migraines. She loses much of her memory regarding that summer. For two years, she is kept away from the island while her family remains tight-lipped about the events. When she finally returns in Summer Seventeen, she finds the island changed: her grandfather has rebuilt his house, and her friends are acting strangely. The narrative follows her fragmented journey to reclaim the truth of what actually happened.

The Truth Revealed

As Cadence's memory returns, she recalls the Liars' plan to destroy the family's main house, Clairmont. They intended the fire to be a symbolic act against their family's greed and the constant fighting over inheritance. However, the plan went horribly wrong. In a tragic twist, Cadence realizes that Johnny, Mirren, and Gat did not survive the fire. The versions of them she has been interacting with during Summer Seventeen are manifestations of her grief and guilt, helping her process the reality of the accident.

Themes for Discussion and Essays

Literature students should focus on the theme of 'The Unreliable Narrator,' as Cadence’s trauma colors the entire story. Additionally, the book offers a critique of 'Inherited Privilege and Racism,' particularly through Gat's outsider status as a person of color in an old-money white family. When writing an essay, consider how the Sinclair motto—'be a credit to the family'—forces the characters to suppress their emotions and the truth, leading to the ultimate tragedy.

Who are the four 'Liars'?

The Liars are Cadence Sinclair Eastman, her cousins Johnny and Mirren, and Gat Patil, the nephew of her aunt's partner.

What is the 'twist' in We Were Liars?

The twist is that Johnny, Mirren, and Gat died in the fire during Summer Fifteen, and Cadence has been hallucinating their presence during her return to the island.

Why is the book titled We Were Liars?

The title refers to the nickname the four friends gave themselves, reflecting both their rebellious nature and the many secrets kept by the Sinclair family to protect their reputation.

Continue in App

Master Your Lit Class with Readi.AI

Don't let complex plots and unreliable narrators slow you down. While sites like SparkNotes or LitCharts offer basic overviews, Readi.AI provides personalized study tools to help you excel. Download Readi.AI on the App Store today to ace your next literature assignment.

Download on App Store Explore Features